Butter vs. Margarine


Posted by Candace Grahl on Just Baking

I’ve been cooking for years and on occasion I have been known to substitute margarine for butter (mainly during my college years when money was tight).  But since I’ve learned more about baking, and made literally hundreds of recipes, I have realized that the two are definitely not equal. 

butter.jpg Butter is made from the fat taken from the cream of sweet milk of domesticated animals, usually cows.  Once the cream is seperated from the milk, it is churned until it reaches a semisolid state and is then formed into blocks of butter.  Margarine is a blend of oils, a combination of both animal and vegetable fats.  It was originally developed as a lower-priced alternative to butter and was said to be healthier as well.  But with the on-going studies of trans-fat in diets, we’re seeing that may not be the case.

In terms of the difference in flavor and texture, I will always choose butter.  While it is more expensive ($.70 for 4 sticks of margarine as opposed to $3 for 4 sticks of butter), the end product is well worth the financial sacrifice.  Margarine tends to flatten baked goods, especially cookies, and doesn’t give much flavor, while butter gives cakes and cookies a nice, light texture and also a rich flavor.

Some people can’t discern the difference between the two, so it really is up to personal preference.  However, there is no real choice in the matter - I like to make things as pure as possible, so in my kitchen, I will always use butter.

Information and Links

Join the fray by commenting, tracking what others have to say, or linking to it from your blog.


Other Posts
Tips To Avoid Holiday Weight Gain: Tip #1
Spirit World Writer is a F&W 1st Place Winner
BlogHer Ad Network
More from BlogHer
Advertise here
BlogHer Privacy Policy

Write a Comment

Take a moment to comment and tell us what you think. Some basic HTML is allowed for formatting.

Reader Comments

I completely agree with you when it comes to butter. I first read about how margarine was made from Dr Hay (of the Hay diet) and it completely put me off using margarine if I can avoid it. There’s nothing like a piece of fresh bread with some real butter spread over it :)

After being told for as long as I can remember that margarine is healthier than butter, I used to balk every time my wife bought butter at Thanksgiving and Christmas to use in various things. This year I decided to take a look at the nutritional information of both our butter and margaring, and I was absolutely floored when I realized how much trans fat was in my “healthy” margarine. I thought that trans fats were only found in highly processed foods and not something as basic as margarine. Now we’ve switched over to butter completely, and so far I’ve been very happy about it. Last week I made my first chocolate chip cookies using butter, and everyone here agreed that they were the best cookies we’ve ever had.

And yes, there is nothing like fresh bread, just minutes out of the oven, with some butter melting over it. Mmmmmmm. :)

[…] Unsalted Butter:  Using unsalted butter will let you know just how much salt is going into your recipe.  While more expensive, it’s important to use butter instead of margarine.  You can buy it when it’s on sale and store it in your freezer for up to four months.  It’s actually recommended you keep your butter frozen until you use it, but that’s really just personal preference. […]

[…] Unsalted Butter:  Using unsalted butter will let you know just how much salt is going into your recipe.  While more expensive, it’s important to use butter instead of margarine.  You can buy it when it’s on sale and store it in your freezer for up to four months.  It’s actually recommended you keep your butter frozen until you use it, but that’s really just personal preference. […]

My grandfather was a dairy farmer and a buttermaker for Lake To Lake Dairy. Saying the M word was a bad thing.